Critic's Choice Catering & Event Production

Nicole Graff
5 Star
Critics went above and beyond for my bridal shower! I had a small rooftop gathering of about 20 gals and Kaycie knew exactly how to handle this type of event. From the menu selection to the set-up, it was absolutely stunning and my guests were raving over the avocado toast bar! I really enjoyed working with Kaycie and her energy is amazing! She is very personable, very professional and because of that, I will continue to use Critics for future events.
Saturday 23rd April 2022

Davis Tran
5 Star
Kaycie is excellent at planning a wedding/creating an event. She is creative, organized, and comes in with great energy. She gives her ideas, but is mindful to ask your input to let things marinate. Kaycie did heavy lifting as our caterer, assisted in final table arrangements and helped us with day-of-coordination. She is an All-Star! Critic's can help you with flowers, centerpieces, décor, and connect you with other vendors. For food, the price is better than many other local caterers (we got quotes from 5). The food is higher quality/tastier than most wedding food we have had. All-in-all, Critic's Choice was an amazing positive force in our wedding. They helped shape our reception into a beautiful, memorable banquet. From the coffee bar to the dessert bar, our guests raved about the options they had. Would recommend to anyone!
Thursday 2nd March 2023

Darian Ubogagu
5 Star
Kaycie and the entire Critics Choice Team was truly amazing! From the first conversation I had with Kaycie it was clear that I had finally found a vendor who was on my side! Kaycie is more than just a caterer but is also an event designer, logistics guru, party planner and everything in between. I first discovered Critics Choice and met Kaycie during April 2020 when I thought my September 2020 wedding was going to happen. Kaycie truly listened to my vision and vibe for the wedding and helped me craft a beautiful menu answering every single one of my questions with patience & clarity. When the time came and we decided to postpone our wedding Kaycie and her team were extremely flexible and willing to work with us! Fast forward to our May 30th 2021 wedding date - Kaycie and her team knocked it out the park. All the food was AMAZING & FLAVORFUL. From the lamb chops to the crab cakes and petit filet mignon served at dinner. Our guests came up to us saying this was the BEST wedding food they had ever ate! Additionally, Kaycie also worked with my Mom to plan the most EPIC Bridal Shower for me! Everything was absolutely amazing from the decor to the champagne with fresh fruit puree dazzled with floral petals. My guests also were obsessed with the tri tip, shrimp and grits, and beautiful cheese grazing station at my bridal shower. In addition, to the food, Kaycie also acted as an party planner for this event and the decor was absolutely incredible it felt like we were transported to a chateau in Italy so many precious photo moments & beautiful decor! Thank you so much Critics Choice & Kaycie
Thursday 3rd June 2021

Caitlin Webster
5 Star
Critics Choice did such a fantastic job with our wedding and we have received so many compliments about how great their food was! I cannot thank Kaycie enough for all of her hard work leading up to and during our big day. She was really committed to making our dream a reality and did such an amazing job putting everything together!
Wednesday 3rd January 2024

Elizabeth Coopersmith
5 Star
Maura created charcuterie boxes for the last wedding I coordinated, and they were delicious! Perfect for cocktail hour appetizers. She was so easy to work with, and very focused on creating a great experience for my couple and their guests.
Wednesday 2nd August 2023